You can create separate Volumes on your Synology DiskStation. What are the benefits? In this post, I collect the reasons to consider creating multiple Volumes or Storage Pools.
Using Volumes On Synology NAS
When you install a Synology NAS for the first time and skip custom options, the process will combine all disks into a single Storage Pool and use that entire pool for a single Volume. If you have multiple disks connected in a single Storage Pool, you will create redundancy or fault tolerance. However, there are other options where you create more Volumes and optionally separate Storage Pools.
In the graphic above you see four disks connected in a single Storage Pool as RAID5. This means that there is a fault tolerance for one disk, hence one red star at the right in the Storage Pool.
On the Storage Pool, there is one Volume, occupying the entire space of the pool. The Volume’s file system is Btrfs.
You can review all these items on your own Synology NAS with the Storage Manager. The Storage Manager is one of the default applications on your NAS and a very powerful tool that gives you all the necessary information about the configuration and health of your disks, pools, and volumes.
What is the purpose of having multiple Volumes on your Synology NAS? Before we dig into this, let’s determine a few facts on how a DiskStation handles Volumes.
Disks, storage pool, and volume
Your DiskStation combines disks into one or more Storage Pools. On each Storage Pool, you create one or more Volumes.
The RAID or SHR level of the Storage Pool determines the kind of redundancy of that pool and, as a result for every Volume on that pool. On a Storage Pool, you create one or more Volumes. You can have multiple Volumes on the same Storage Pool or create separate Storage Pools with their Volume.
The terms RAID and SHR (Synology Hybrid RAID) are often used randomly. However, SHR is Synology’s own implementation of RAID.
A Volume is limited in size. Older and some recent base models have a 16TB limit, and for other models, the limit is 108TB up to 200TB. A Volume has a file system. On a Synology DiskStation, you can choose between the basic EXT4 and the more advanced Btrfs file system.
Note that some DiskStaton models only support EXT4 as a file system.
There are (at least) three features of DSM related to using Volumes on Synology NAS. DSM or DiskStation Manager is the operating system of your Synology DiskStation.
When you install a package, create a shared folder, or enable the user Home Service, you can select a Volume if more than one exists on your NAS. Note that there are a few packages that do not offer Volume selection.
When using Volumes on Synology NAS it is important to understand the different formats of a Volume. You format a Volume with a file system. Most Synology NAS models let you choose between Btrfs and EXT4. Some – typically basic models – support EXT4 only. The Btrfs file system is more versatile, whereas EXT4 gives higher performance.
The graph above highlights some of the differences. For example, with the EXT4 file system, a quota is only enforced per Volume, not per Shared Folder, as is the case with Btrfs. As a result, where quotas are concerned, you could be more inclined to create multiple Volumes with the EXT4 file system. For a detailed explanation about quota, please reference Using quota on Synology NAS.
On the other hand, you might create a separate Volume with EXT4 for applications like Surveillance Station or a website.
To speed up read and write access to your HD drives, you can use an SSD cache. A cache is beneficial for repeated access to the same information. For NAS models that support an SSD cache, it is good to know that a cache is assigned per Volume.
Up to DSM 7.0.1, you can assign your cache to a single Volume only. From DSM 7.1 this is expanded to up to eight Volumes on the same Storage Pool. This makes using Volumes on Synology NAS even more flexible.
Let us now look at some decisions you could make when designing Storage Pools and Volumes in a Synology DiskStation.
Separate Types Of Data
You can store different kinds of data on different Volumes for a better overview. You do not necessarily have to create separate Storage Pools for each Volume, but you could.
For example, you have all the user home folders on one Volume and all Shared Folders on the other. Or you might install services and applications from Synology packages on a specific Volume separated from other data.
When you backup other computers to your Synology NAS, you might want to create a separate Volume for that.
Some DiskStation models have the option to extend their capacity with an expansion unit. Synology offers different expansion units like the DX517 and DX1215 desktop models and several rack-mount models.
Best practices for these expansion units tell us to create a Storage Pool separate from the main chassis. In other words, do not combine drives in the DiskStation’s main chassis with drives in the expansion unit into a single Storage Pool. This will degrade performance significantly.
Some services or applications require a specific file system, like Btrfs. Examples are the Virtual Machine Manager application and Snapshots. Other applications are more suited to the EXT4 file system, like a website.
A file system is a property of a Volume. Note that you can create multiple Volumes on the same Storage Pool.
Understanding the different kinds of data is important when using Volumes on Synology NAS.
You always have multiple Volumes with different Storage Pools because you have at least one Volume per Storage Pool. You can not span a Volume over different Storage Pools.
You can give each Storage Pool its specific RAID configuration depending on the need for redundancy, storage, or performance characteristics.
Your movie collection, for example, is static and may grow slowly over the years. Assuming you have a backup, redundancy is not a requirement, but storage space is. You can sacrifice redundancy for space and create a separate Storage Pool and Volume for it.
Your data in Shared Folders, on the other hand, is very dynamic, and availability is paramount. A high level of redundancy is mandatory.
Storing your movie collection on a separate Storage Pool, and therefore Volume makes a lot of sense. Note that different data can have different backup schedules. I will mention this below.
When you separate data over different Storage Pools, you might achieve better performance. For example, while one pool is storing a backup, another pool can serve data to users. The disks will become less of a bottle-neck, assuming you have HDDs, not SSDs.
Talking SSD: an SSD cache is assigned per Volume. You can collect data that benefit from a cache on a single Volume that you assign the cache to, separate from data that do not benefit from a cache.
Maintenance And Backup
When a Volume or Storage Pool fills up, you only need to upgrade the disks for that pool, not the entire disk set in your DiskStation. This makes maintenance easier. When you backup data per Volume, you can backup dynamic data more frequently than other data that is more static.
While talking about an expansion unit with its own Storage Pool, you can use this unit exclusively for one of your backups.
What Do You Think
Do you use multiple volumes in a single NAS? How did you set this up, and what goal was achieved?
When designing your NAS in terms of disks, Storage Pools, and Volumes, I suggest you first make an inventory of the different kinds of data that you like to store on it. Next, you translate that into Volumes and their file system.
With your list of Volumes, you translate that into Storage Pools. You have the option to combine Volumes on a single Storage Pool or divide them over different pools. This obviously depends on the disks you have available.
It may be clear that a DiskStation with 5 bays is more flexible in terms of Volumes and Storage Pools than a 2-bay model.
Thanks for reading
This post is donation-ware, and I made it to help you. Please consider leaving a comment or even buying me a coffee if it did. I will be eternally grateful.
Paul Steunebrink / Storage Alchemist
2 thoughts on “Using Volumes On Synology NAS”
Thanks Paul. I’ve had a Synology DS415play since ’15, and have it (1 pool) separated into 3 volumes, which I haven’t really used beyond volume 1. Having realized the limitations with that 32 bit machine, and wanting to be able to use docker and some other apps like mail station plus which won’t run on that, I just purchased a DS1520+. I’m trying to figure out how best to organize everything, and am at a loss as to whether I should go with more than 1 volume, or even more than one storage pool . I got 5 WD red plus’s for it (CRMs) in a package deal from B&H Photo, installed them all but 2 were DOA and I sent them back for replacement. Waiting for them now, but the other 3 are in and running SHR1 in 1 pool and 1 volume. When I get the replacement 2, I assume it will allow me to add as new pool and/or a 2nd volume. In looking around a bit on the internet your article seems to offer the most comprehension with regard to pools and volumes.
With regard to adding new drives and the ability to create a new pool, versus adding to an existing pool, I do not have this experience firsthand. What I read is that drives are added automatically to the existing pool but maybe there is an option that users overlook that will allow you to choose a different configuration (I would expect it does).
Whether or not separate pools and volumes are beneficial to your setup, depends on the kind of data, the static or dynamic nature, performance requirements, file system etc. what I outline in the post. I suggest you write down for yourself what it is that you want to achieve. These requirements translate into the desired configuration.
Best regards, Paul Steunebrink / Storage Alchemist